There is blood on the streets today.21st November,2007.I would have quite easily discarded this date-brushed it off as an inconsequential day.Fate,however,was to have other plans in store for me.
When the violence took place,I was comfortably sleeping in bed...undisturbed by the goings-on outside.I live in an area which is not very far from Park Circus,which has been the chosen target for these idiots.
By saying "these idiots"(which they are,without a shadow of doubt),I run the risk of sounding rather glib,so let me first give you a gist of what happened today,or at least my understanding of it.A minority group decided to attack Taslima Nasreen,A Bangladeshi Writer who has been banned from entering her own country and has been living for several months in kolkata on an Indian Visa.Her famous Works include 'Amar Meyebela'or 'My Girlhood'and 'Dwikhondito'which literally translates as split into two parts.Bangladesh is a theocratic country and follows Islam as their state religion.Being in Bangladesh means that you cannot say negative things about the Islamic Religion.
In India,however,that is not the case...we are a "Sovereign,Socialist,Secular,Democratic Republic"(at least on paper).This means that we are allowed to speak our minds on any religion and we are allowed to have are differences and at the same time live in peace and harmony.As Indians,or even as Citizens of the World,we have the right to Co-exist.
Taslima Nasreen,however,faced the ire of Bangladeshis in general, with her critique of the Islamic Religion.While I am by no means criticising Bangladesh for their decision to expel Taslima Nasreen(it is not in my place to do so),when I heard that Taslima had been granted an Indian Visa,I respected the governments decision not because I personally propagate Taslima's view of Islam(because I don't. I personally feel it is rather attention seeking and brutal to the point of being offensive)But what I admired was the fact that our government defended the right of an individual to speak her mind.
And then....today...something astounding happened.A riot broke out in kolkata.(I personally believe that the riot was communal or at least had the propensity to become a communal riot.)
But today,at around nine,people burnt paper effigies on the streets and displayed placards saying "go back taslima"and the violence took on a communal colour and reached monumental proportions.
This is what the BBC had to say:
Police using tear gas and baton charges were unable to control crowds calling for Bangladeshi feminist writer Taslima Nasreen to leave India
Rioters blocked roads and set cars alight. At least 27 people were hurt. More than 100 arrests have been made.
Crowds were also protesting at recent attacks on Muslims in the Nandigram area in the east of West Bengal state.
A number of people have been killed and thousands left homeless in Nandigram after violence over now-abandoned state plans to industrialise farm land in the area.
Wednesday's trouble in the state capital began after the predominantly Muslim All-India Minority Forum called for blockades on major roads in the city.
The group said Ms Nasreen had "seriously hurt Muslim sentiments". Many Muslims say her writing ridicules Islam.
Police arrived in strength to disperse the demonstrators.
Violence then broke out in Ripon Street in the north of the city and spread to Park Circus, Moulali and many other areas of central Calcutta.
The BBC's Subir Bhaumik in Calcutta says he saw two army columns, one in Park Circus and one in Moulali.
For most of the day, parts of the city centre were a no-go area, with main roads closed to traffic and commuters stranded.
Children spent hours in buses before they could be returned to the safety of their schools.
My sister and my brother were both at school and I feared for their safety.My mother told me that schools like Pratt Memorial,St James's School,Don Bosco Park Circus and even Modern High School For Girls(my school)were in the danger area.
Modern High School For Girls is now hosting their annual Fest Maitree and St James is one school that is taking part. My sister tells me that most participants couldn't turn up.The five boys that were already in modern high school sportingly took part in all the events.
It's very strange how normal life gets disrupted following gruesome political factionalism.After the Nandigram Attacks,people felt that the way in which the ruling party in West Bengal(CPIM) did not hesitate to use the state machinery to meet its own narrow political needs was condemnable.Many petitions were signed and on the 14nth of November,A silent rally comprising almost 60,000 people began marching from College Square Onwards.
Some people think that the police are to blame and that they have "failed the people continually".Others think that thegovernment is to blame and should be dispatched of.Yet others feel,that an intellectual(from the film fraternity,perhaps?)should be made Chief Minister.
In Kolkata,Anarchy Rages....and the colour of violence and hatred spews out distasteful venom...
I don't know whether another test match will ever be played in Kolkata...or whether another film festival will take place(they boycotted that as well this year)
This is not the city I know,or recognise.
Close
For those who have read my blog earlier know that I believe that the occurences of November 21st was a Communal Riot and that the phrase is on my blog.I updating it by featuring in it news from the BBC so I can substantiate the claims of someone who thought I was "irresponsible"and that I should "post a rejoinder"I can't change the world,but I can back my opinions by factual statements.So I've done it.I have also corrected all the typos and syntactic errors that I had made previously.
Reply | | Report Abuse
Some people in the world just don't make sense.They are dogmatic in their approach,and yet they expect other people to be kind to them.They hate being called stupid,but they feel pity "for the elders of the persons family"and claim that they are not being abusive.They harp on "Freedom of Expression"and it when it comes to another's Freedom of Expression,they expect it to be laid down by them and built on their own value systems and beliefs,which they declare as the "truth".The .And yet,even if they don't make sense,I guess I'll have to live with it.
Reply | | Report Abuse
Minister Manmohan Singh has conveyed to his colleagues that no government should succumb to the "blackmail"tactics of fundamendalist elements from any religion,sources close to him said.
Reply | | Report Abuse
If we were to think this way and just let it all happen, thinking that the trouble makers will be punished by god then we are basically encouraging them aren't we? I mean if we allow this to happen and depend on god( and we dont really know if there is one at all) to do all the sinner bashing then it would be wrong on our part as well.
This needs to stop and people need to start learning to sort out their priorities, too many of us even in our everyday lives interfere in other people's business, that too unnecessarily, we all need to realise the fine line between what is our concern and what is not. The developement plans were actually none of the concerns of the various political parties, the entire process of carrying out the barricading lands and all the atrocities that happened since then were basically because too many people interfered in it.
It is sad indeed but some solution needs to be found and it needs to be quick, otherwise we are all going to be in line for greater trouble which will probably end in us all being wiped out by each other.
Reply | | Report Abuse
What you have written is really sad.
If there is God, such wrongs should not happen.
But God's ways are mysterious. He is always protecting
humans against sins & degradation.
Reply | | Report Abuse
I agree with that as well. The original intention of developement was good, we all know how poor a condition the farmers used to have to live in anyway, judging by what TATA did to Jamshedpur, he may well have been trusted upon, but the party politics got in the way and villified an originally decent intention
Reply | | Report Abuse
Sir,I believe you meant that it would have been better if they thought about their party politics later and the national interest first,in which case I totally agree with you.
Reply | | Report Abuse
The CPM is getting a kind of poetic justice at the hands of the villagers of Nandigram. The tangle of land acquisition has taken such a shape. But the left parties are doing the same thing while mindlessly opposing UPA Government’s economic measures: setting up of SEZs, attracting FDIs, reforming labour laws, to name a few. Had they treated the economic issues on purely economic grounds, had they kept party politics above national interest, they would have successfully maintained their bold face.
Reply | | Report Abuse
Elitism is the belief or attitude that those individuals who are considered members of the elite — a select group of people with outstanding personal abilities, intellect, wealth, specialized training or experience, or other distinctive attributes — are those whose views on a matter are to be taken the most seriously or carry the most weight; whose views and/or actions are most likely to be constructive to society as a whole; or whose extraordinary skills, abilities or wisdom render them especially fit to govern .
Mr Datta,
you don't know how happy you've made me by calling me an elitist.Thank you so much.
"You can call me stupid but be honest to yourself. Instead of lecturing me to respect others judgement - I believe you need the same more urgently. I said - use of "communal riot" which did not happen was irresponsible. I suppose "Communal riot" was a typo ,which was removed in the editing. Even if you do not admit,you know it and those who read it because it was show cased.know it.
Please be happy."
I stand by what I said about communal riots
Thanks for caring so much about my well-being
Reply | | Report Abuse
Mr Datta,
Since when have my comments suggested that I am targetting Islam as the only religion with religious fundamentalism? Off course all religions do and the biggest example would be that of the Brahmin hypocrisies throughout the ages; something that was portrayed in Deepa Mehta's Water. But you seem to be hell bent on correcting Reeti's terming the conflicts in Kolkata as Communal, when in all truth they were exactly what she has called them-A Communal Problem fuelled by party workers.
The CPI(M) did not object to Taslima Nasreen's staying in India before because they were too busy helping hack up the poor villagers nandigram. Plus I dont believe the bulk of the party members of CPI(M) are Islamics, which is why they cared a damn about what a muslim woman regarding about the atrocities they face.
I dont know about the rest of the society since I do not take it as a bench mark for my beliefs, but I certainly respect Taslima and as far the society is concerned, they don't really care a damn about she has written either because it is the same society which oppresses women in other forms. They seem to be suporting Taslima because it is those who are against her, who have created havoc in the city. So this is more an Enemy of Enemy =Friend scenario. Honestly speaking the society is too chauvinist in Kolkata too in order to care, so there goes your answer as to why the society is going ga ga over Nasreen, it is because they have nothing better to do.
Joe B R
Reply | | Report Abuse
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
Displaying 1 - 10 of 48 Blog Comments